Global Mortgage Calculator

Appraisal Came in Low? Your 5 Options, With Numbers

A home appraiser with a clipboard inspecting the exterior of a house after the appraisal came in low.

The contract is signed, the moving boxes are ordered — and then the appraisal came in low. Buyers ask about it in almost identical words: what are the consequences if the appraisal comes in lower than the value I entered when applying? The short answer: your lender will lend against the lower number, and the difference must be solved by you, by the seller, by a successful challenge to the appraisal — or the deal dies. Here is what each path actually costs.

Cash to Close After a Low Appraisal
Cover the gap in cash$104,000Split the difference$91,500ROV raises value to price$84,000Renegotiate price to $395K$79,000

Below: the one rule that decides everything, a worked purchase example with a $25,000 gap, all five options side by side, how to fight the value with a reconsideration of value, what an appraisal gap clause really commits you to, and what a low appraisal does to a refinance.

What are the consequences if the appraisal comes in lower than the value you entered?

One rule drives everything: your lender bases the loan on the lower of the contract price and the appraised value. Agree to pay $420,000 for a home that appraises at $395,000, and as far as the lender is concerned you are buying a $395,000 home. Your maximum loan, your loan-to-value ratio (LTV) and any private mortgage insurance (PMI) requirement are all recalculated against $395,000. The $25,000 difference is the appraisal gap, and no lender will finance it.

You also have a legal right to see the number you are fighting. Under the Equal Credit Opportunity Act's valuations rule, your lender must give you a free copy of the appraisal promptly after it is completed, and no later than three business days before closing — a deadline you can waive, but should not. As the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau explains, you cannot be charged for the copy. Read it before choosing an option: its comparable sales are the ammunition for option 4 below.

A $420,000 contract and a $395,000 appraisal: the worked example

Say you signed at $420,000 with 20% down: $84,000 down and a loan of $336,000. The appraisal lands at $395,000. The maximum loan is now 80% of $395,000 — $316,000 — and the appraisal gap is $25,000. If the price does not move and you close anyway, cash to close becomes $420,000 − $316,000 = $104,000, not $84,000. That recalculation is the whole problem; every option below answers it differently. Check the loan still fits your budget at the new numbers in our mortgage affordability calculator.

Your 5 options when the appraisal came in low

OptionHow it worksCash to close in the exampleMain trade-off
1. Cover the gap in cashPrice stays $420,000; you pay the difference the lender will not finance.$104,000 (loan $316,000)Drains cash you may need for moving, repairs and reserves.
2. Renegotiate the priceSeller cuts the price to the appraised value of $395,000.$79,000 (20% of $395,000; loan $316,000)Seller may refuse, especially with backup offers waiting.
3. Split the differenceMeet in the middle: price $407,500, each side absorbs half the gap.$91,500 (price minus the $316,000 loan)You still pay above appraised value for part of the gap.
4. Reconsideration of valueChallenge the appraisal with better comparable sales or factual corrections.$84,000 if the value is raised to $420,000Costs days to weeks; no guarantee the value moves.
5. Walk awayExit under your appraisal contingency, if you kept one.Earnest money refunded; appraisal and inspection fees already paid are lostYou lose the house and restart your search.

Most deals that survive use options 2 or 3: sellers who have already mentally moved out rarely let a sale die over part of a gap, and the appraisal itself is strong evidence the price overshot the market. Option 1 makes sense only when the home is hard to replace and your reserves stay healthy after closing. Option 5 is the one your contract either protects or does not — which is why contingencies matter before you sign, not after.

Can I fight the appraisal value? How a reconsideration of value works

Yes — the formal route is a reconsideration of value (ROV). You (usually through your lender, often with your agent's help) submit comparable sales the appraiser missed or used wrongly, plus factual errors in the report: wrong square footage, a missing bedroom, a renovation not credited. As the CFPB sets out, borrowers may point out factual errors or omissions and inadequate comparable properties, and the lender's ROV process must be available to every borrower on the same terms.

Set expectations correctly. An ROV goes back to the same appraiser, who may raise the value, adjust it slightly, or decline to change it. Your lender will not simply order a second appraisal because the first came in low — a new appraisal is generally ordered only if the ROV shows the original report was materially deficient. On a purchase, a second appraisal is therefore difficult by design: appraisal independence rules exist precisely so nobody can shop for a friendlier number. Argue with evidence, not with the price you agreed to pay.

Under contract with an appraisal gap clause? Read it before you panic

If your offer included an appraisal gap clause (gap coverage), you have already promised to cover some or all of a shortfall in cash, up to a stated cap. A low appraisal then does not let you renegotiate or walk away below that cap — you have pre-agreed to option 1 within the limit. Check the cap against your actual cash before assuming the worst: a $25,000 gap against a $30,000 cap is uncomfortable, not fatal. And filing an ROV does not weaken your position: it runs between you, your lender and the appraiser, the seller is not involved, and your contract obligations stay exactly as written while it is pending.

The appraisal came in low on my refinance — is 84.4% LTV a big deal?

A refinance has no seller and no contract, so a low appraisal cannot kill the deal the same way — it just reprices it. Take a $380,000 loan you expected to sit at 76% LTV against a $500,000 value. The appraisal comes in at $450,000, and the same loan is now 84.4% LTV. The loan is not denied — but crossing the 80% line usually means PMI is added and rate pricing worsens, which can quietly erase the savings the refinance was for.

You have four moves. File an ROV if the comparables are genuinely weak. Accept the PMI, knowing it can usually be removed once you reach 80% LTV. Pay the loan down to $360,000 — 80% of $450,000 — which costs $20,000 of extra principal but restores the original terms. Or wait and reapply when values or your balance improve. Which wins depends on how long the PMI would actually last, so run both versions through our mortgage refinance calculator. And if the value came in low but still funds the loan on the terms you wanted, the honest answer to “is it a big deal?” is no — a refinance that still saves you money has done its job.

Why a seller might accept a cash offer that is 4% lower

The same logic explains a puzzle from the seller's side: why take a cash or no-contingency offer priced about 4% below a higher financed offer? Because every contingency is a way the deal can fail. A financed offer carries the appraisal risk described in this entire article, plus underwriting and inspection exits; a cash offer with waived contingencies removes all of them. Sellers are not irrational when they discount for certainty — they are pricing the probability that the higher offer never reaches the closing table. As a financed buyer, a gap clause, a larger earnest deposit or a pre-approval that has already been through underwriting — see our guide to mortgage pre-approval — buys back some of that certainty without matching the cash price.

The bottom line

An appraisal that comes in low is a math problem with five solutions, not a verdict on the house. The lender will use the lower value; the gap must be covered in cash, negotiated away, split, challenged through a reconsideration of value, or escaped through your contingency. Get your free copy of the appraisal early, read its comparable sales before you argue, and price each option in dollars — including the closing costs you would pay again if you walk away and start over. This article is educational only and is not financial or legal advice.

Frequently asked questions

What are the consequences if the appraisal comes in lower than the value I entered when applying?

Your lender recalculates everything against the appraised value, because the loan is based on the lower of the contract price and the appraisal. The maximum loan shrinks, your loan-to-value ratio rises, and the difference — the appraisal gap — has to come from somewhere: more cash from you, a lower price from the seller, a successful challenge to the value, or the deal ends under your appraisal contingency. On a refinance, a low value mainly changes your LTV, which can add PMI and move you into a worse pricing tier.

Can I get a second appraisal if the first one comes in low?

Usually not just by asking. Lenders will not order a second appraisal simply because you dislike the first number — the standard route is a reconsideration of value (ROV), where the original appraiser re-examines the report against better comparable sales or factual corrections. A genuinely new appraisal is generally only ordered when the ROV shows the first report was materially deficient, or by switching lenders and starting over, which costs time and a second appraisal fee.

My appraisal came in low but still high enough for my refinance — is it a big deal?

Often, no. If the loan still closes on the terms you wanted, a lower appraised value is mostly a paper disappointment. It becomes a real cost only when it pushes your LTV across a pricing boundary — above 80% it usually adds PMI, and tiers at 85%, 90% and 95% LTV carry progressively worse rate adjustments. Run the new LTV before you react: if nothing about the loan changes, nothing needs fixing.

Does asking for a reconsideration of value weaken my position with the seller?

No. An ROV is a private process between you, your lender and the appraiser — the seller is not a party to it and normally never sees the request. It does not reopen your contract or change your obligations under an appraisal gap clause. The only real cost is time: an ROV can take days to a couple of weeks, so start it immediately and keep your closing timeline in view.

We found out the house needs a new roof after our offer was accepted — should we get our own inspection before closing?

Yes — that is exactly what the inspection contingency is for, and you should use your own independent inspector rather than relying on the seller's disclosures or the appraiser (the appraisal values the home; it is not a condition report). If the inspection confirms a major defect like a roof at the end of its life, you can typically ask for a repair, a price credit, or walk away within the contingency window. After closing, the same problem is yours alone, so never waive the inspection to save a few days.

Related calculators & guides

About the Global Mortgage Calculator Team

The Global Mortgage Calculator Team builds the mortgage, HELOC and refinance calculators on this site and keeps them aligned with how US lenders actually price loans. Every calculator uses the standard amortization formulas set out in our methodology, is tested against worked examples before release, and our rate commentary is tied to published data — Freddie Mac's weekly survey and Federal Reserve releases — never to opinion.

How our calculators work·More about the team