FHA vs Conventional: Which Wins With Under 20% Down?

Put FHA vs conventional side by side with less than 20% down and FHA looks like the easy winner: 3.5% down, forgiving credit rules, and rates that are often a touch lower. One forum poster summed up the suspicion perfectly: FHA seems to be a home run — what am I missing? What you are missing is the mortgage insurance. Both loans charge it when you put down under 20%, but they charge it very differently — and over the years you hold the loan, that difference is usually bigger than the rate difference that made FHA look cheap.
Below: the head-to-head table, the four catches hidden in FHA's fine print, a worked example on a $350,000 home with 5% down, whether paying $32,000 extra just to dodge PMI is worth it, and when FHA genuinely is the better loan. The CFPB's mortgage insurance explainer confirms the core mechanics: FHA insurance is required on every FHA loan, is priced the same whatever your credit score, and is paid both up front and monthly, while conventional PMI is priced by credit and can be cancelled.
FHA vs conventional at a glance
| FHA | Conventional | |
|---|---|---|
| Minimum down payment | 3.5% (10% if credit score is 500-579) | 3% on first-time / HomeReady / Home Possible programs; 5% typical |
| Upfront premium | 1.75% of the base loan (UFMIP), usually rolled into the loan | None for monthly PMI |
| Monthly insurance | Annual MIP 0.55% for most 30-year loans, paid monthly | PMI priced by credit score and LTV — roughly 0.2%-1%+ a year |
| Insurance ends when | After 11 years if you put 10%+ down; otherwise only by refinancing or paying off | You can request cancellation at 80% LTV; automatic at 78% |
| Minimum credit (typical) | 580 for 3.5% down; 500 for 10% down | 620 typical lender minimum |
| Appraisal strictness | Stricter — FHA appraisal includes property-condition standards | Standard appraisal; condition requirements are lighter |
| Best for | Weaker credit, thin savings, higher debt ratios | Good credit and a plan to reach 20% equity |
Two rows decide most real cases: the upfront premium and the "insurance ends when" row. Everything else is close enough that borrowers fixate on the rate — but read on before you do.
FHA vs conventional: FHA seems to be a home run — what's the catch?
The poster was right to ask about fine print. There are four catches, and together they explain why FHA's lower rate often loses:
- MIP lasts (almost) the life of the loan. On FHA loans endorsed after 3 June 2013 with less than 10% down, the annual MIP never drops off — you pay it in year 20 exactly as in year 1, unless you refinance out. Put 10% or more down and it cancels after 11 years. Conventional PMI, by contrast, is removable at 80% LTV and terminates automatically at 78%.
- The upfront premium. FHA charges 1.75% of the base loan amount at closing — the UFMIP. Almost everyone finances it, which means you start the loan owing more than the home's purchase price minus your down payment, and you pay interest on the premium for as long as you hold the loan.
- Stricter property standards. The FHA appraisal is also a condition inspection: peeling paint, roof problems, missing handrails and similar defects can block the loan until the seller fixes them. In a competitive market, sellers know this — and sometimes pick a conventional offer over an FHA one for exactly that reason.
- Loan limits. FHA lending is capped at county-level limits that trail conventional conforming limits in expensive areas. Above the FHA limit, conventional (or a jumbo loan) is the only route regardless of insurance costs.
The worked example: a $350,000 home with 5% down
Take a $350,000 purchase, 5% down ($17,500), and a base loan of $332,500. To isolate the insurance, give both loans the same hypothetical 6.75% rate over 30 years — this is an illustration, not a rate quote. On the FHA side, the UFMIP is 1.75% × $332,500 = $5,818.75, rolled into the loan for a total of $338,318.75. Principal and interest come to $2,194.33 a month, and the annual MIP of 0.55% adds $152.40 a month: a total of $2,346.72 before taxes and insurance.
On the conventional side there is no upfront premium, so principal and interest on $332,500 are $2,156.59. PMI estimated at 0.45% a year — a mid-range figure for a decent credit score at 95% LTV — adds $124.69 a month, for a total of $2,281.28. Conventional starts about $65 a month cheaper despite the identical rate, because FHA's borrower is paying interest on the financed UFMIP plus a higher insurance rate. Then the gap widens: amortization alone carries the conventional balance to 80% LTV ($280,000) in about month 127, and most borrowers get there years sooner through appreciation or extra payments — at which point the $124.69 disappears entirely, while the FHA borrower is still paying MIP. Run your own figures in our FHA loan calculator and PMI calculator.
Is paying $32,000 extra up front just to avoid PMI worth it?
One borrower considered adding roughly $32,000 to the down payment purely to cross the 20% line and never pay PMI. It feels clean — no monthly insurance line, ever — but price the thing you are avoiding. On the example above, PMI is about $125 a month, or $1,496 a year, and it is temporary: it ends at 80% LTV by request or 78% automatically. If you would reach that point in three years anyway, the total PMI avoided is on the order of $4,000-4,500. Paying $32,000 of extra cash today to save about $4,500 of premiums is a poor trade unless that cash had no other job — and for most buyers it does: moving costs, repairs, and an emergency fund all outrank PMI avoidance.
Two qualifications. The extra $32,000 also shrinks the loan, saving interest at the loan's rate on every dollar — if you would otherwise hold the cash in a low-yield account, a bigger down payment can win on the combined math. And if your PMI quote is at the expensive end (weaker credit pushes PMI above 1% a year), the premium avoided grows fast. Get the actual figure from your loan estimate before deciding — our PMI removal guide covers both the avoidance and removal routes.
Am I crazy to temporarily pay PMI — and should I recast?
No — paying PMI for a limited stretch is a normal, often rational strategy, and another poster asking exactly this had the right instinct. PMI is rent on the lender's risk: you pay it while your equity is thin, and the exit doors are wide. You can request cancellation at 80% LTV (a new appraisal can establish the value if the home has risen), it terminates automatically at 78%, and every extra principal payment pulls the date closer.
A recast pairs well with that plan. If a lump sum arrives later — a bonus, an inheritance, the sale of a previous home — you pay it against the principal and the lender re-amortizes the smaller balance over the remaining term for a modest fee (a few hundred dollars is typical), cutting the monthly payment. If the lump sum takes the balance to 80% of the original value or below, you can request PMI removal at the same time. One caution: a recast does not change your rate or term, and the PMI exit is based on the original value for the scheduled tests — appreciation-based removal needs the appraisal route instead.
When FHA actually wins
None of the above makes FHA a bad loan — it makes it a specialized one. FHA wins when the borrower's profile is the problem: a credit score in the low 600s or below, where conventional PMI is priced punitively or the application is declined; a 3.5% down payment with a score of 580-619, where FHA's flat MIP beats risk-priced PMI; or a debt-to-income ratio above conventional limits. FHA also wins as a bridge: buy now, build equity, then refinance into a conventional loan at 20% equity and leave MIP behind. Eligible for a VA loan instead? The math changes again — no monthly mortgage insurance at all; see our VA loan calculator and the entitlement question in the FAQ.
The bottom line
With under 20% down, the FHA vs conventional decision is really an insurance decision. Conventional PMI is risk-priced, starts with no upfront premium, and — decisively — ends at 80% LTV. FHA's MIP is flat-priced and forgiving to qualify for, but it charges 1.75% up front and, under 10% down, follows you for the life of the loan. Good credit with a path to 20% equity: conventional, and treat PMI as a temporary toll rather than a reason to drain $32,000 of cash. Weaker credit or a thin file: FHA, ideally with a refinance planned for the day you reach 20% equity. This article is educational only and is not financial advice.
Frequently asked questions
Can PMI really be canceled after 2 years of good payment history?
On a conventional loan, broadly yes — that popular claim is mostly right. Under the Homeowners Protection Act you may ask your servicer in writing to cancel PMI once the balance reaches 80% of the home's original value, and servicers typically require a good payment history (no 30-day lates in the past year, no 60-day lates in the past two years) and no junior liens. PMI terminates automatically at 78% LTV on the original schedule. None of this applies to FHA loans: FHA's charge is MIP, not PMI, and it follows FHA's own duration rules below.
Does FHA mortgage insurance (MIP) ever go away?
Usually not. For FHA loans endorsed after 3 June 2013, MIP stays for the life of the loan if you put down less than 10% — the only exits are paying the loan off or refinancing into a non-FHA loan. If you put down 10% or more, MIP drops off after 11 years. That single rule is why so many FHA borrowers plan an eventual refinance into a conventional loan once they reach 20% equity.
Is it worth paying extra up front just to avoid PMI?
Run the size of the PMI first. On a $332,500 conventional loan, PMI at an estimated 0.45% a year is about $125 a month — roughly $1,496 a year. Tying up $32,000 of extra down payment purely to skip that makes sense only if the PMI would otherwise run for many years; if appreciation, extra principal payments or a recast will get you to 80% LTV within two or three years, the total PMI paid is a few thousand dollars at most, and keeping the $32,000 liquid is usually worth more. The extra down payment also earns the loan's interest rate on every dollar, though, so the comparison is PMI saved plus interest saved against what the cash would earn elsewhere.
Which loan is cheaper if my credit score is strong — or weak?
Strong credit favors conventional. PMI is priced by credit score and LTV, so a borrower in the mid-700s pays a low PMI rate that ends at 80% LTV, while FHA charges the same MIP to everyone and (under 10% down) never removes it. Weak or thin credit flips the answer: conventional PMI gets expensive or the loan is denied outright, while FHA allows 3.5% down at a 580 score and 10% down between 500 and 579, with flat insurance pricing. Check both totals in our FHA loan calculator and PMI calculator rather than comparing rates alone.
How do you compute VA entitlement, and what does it indicate?
Entitlement is the amount the VA will guarantee on your loan — effectively 25% of the loan. Every eligible veteran starts with basic entitlement of $36,000, which alone supports a loan of $144,000 (4 x $36,000). Bonus (second-tier) entitlement covers larger loans up to the county loan limit: total entitlement is 25% of that limit, minus any entitlement already used on an earlier VA loan. The figure indicates how much you can borrow with no down payment: if 25% of your loan amount fits inside your remaining entitlement, no down payment is required; above it, you typically pay 25% of the gap. Our VA loan calculator shows the funding fee side of the same loan.
Related calculators & guides
About the Global Mortgage Calculator Team
The Global Mortgage Calculator Team builds the mortgage, HELOC and refinance calculators on this site and keeps them aligned with how US lenders actually price loans. Every calculator uses the standard amortization formulas set out in our methodology, is tested against worked examples before release, and our rate commentary is tied to published data — Freddie Mac's weekly survey and Federal Reserve releases — never to opinion.